Software

IBM: German companies are developing sovereignty strategies, but there remains a gap between self-assessment and verifiable IT controls

November 11, 2026. A new study by IBM (NYSE: IBM) titled “Proof, Not Promises: The Digital Sovereignty Index” reveals a significant gap: While executives are confident they can demonstrate control over critical AI systems, technologies, operations, and data—they often lack the actual evidence to back this up.

Share this Post

Contact info

Silicon Saxony

Marketing, Kommunikation und Öffentlichkeitsarbeit

Manfred-von-Ardenne-Ring 20 F

Telefon: +49 351 8925 886

redaktion@silicon-saxony.de

The index examined organizations’ ability to maintain and demonstrate control over their AI technology, operations, and data, even as conditions change or dependencies come under pressure. This control is currently being put to the test, causing digital sovereignty to evolve from a technology issue into a matter of resilience, business performance, and board-level accountability. Nearly all German companies surveyed (93%) recently experienced at least one incident that tested their sovereignty. These include AI issues, regulatory audits, cyberattacks, or changes in vendors. While most maintained control, 68 percent of the affected German companies subsequently had to provide formal evidence to regulatory authorities, customers, auditors, or internal stakeholders.

“German companies are investing heavily in resilient and sovereign infrastructures, but our study shows that technical control alone is not enough,” says Wolfgang Wendt, Chairman of the Management Board of IBM Germany. “If evidence is missing in an emergency or if gathering documentation paralyzes operations, the inability to demonstrate sovereignty quickly and without interruption becomes a real business risk. Digital sovereignty must evolve from a mere compliance requirement into a lived practice that can be demonstrated at any time in day-to-day business operations.”

Lack of Evidence Leads to Business Disruptions 

The study shows that the gap between companies’ self-assessments and their actual ability to provide evidence is particularly wide in Germany. While 80 percent of respondents in Germany were confident they could demonstrate control over their AI, technology, operational processes, and data, only 18 percent achieved the index’s highest standard, the “Leading Evidence” level —compared to 26 percent globally and trailing behind competitors in the U.S. and the U.K. This level represents comprehensive, well-integrated governance and operational controls, supported by the ability to provide well-founded, comprehensive, and consistently documented evidence across the entire organization.

The results suggest that the challenge generally does not lie in a lack of controls. More than half of German companies (51%) were at the “Consistent Evidence” level when it came to demonstrating sovereignty; however, their sovereignty measures are often not designed to provide evidence quickly and seamlessly under pressure.

For German companies currently grappling with their sovereignty strategies, the next decisions are of great importance. The impact of these sovereignty challenges is clear: Only 19 percent of German companies reported having resolved a sovereignty incident without significant business disruption. Among the biggest hurdles to the rapid provision of evidence are outdated legacy systems (60%) and a highly manual evidence-gathering process (60%). Furthermore, clearly assigning responsibilities proves difficult. These challenges highlight the most obvious opportunity for improvement: By breaking down data silos, improving the transparency of data and processes, and strengthening continuous validation, organizations can overcome these bottlenecks and enhance their operational resilience.

Artificial Intelligence as the Ultimate Stress Test

At 35 percent, AI-related incidents in Germany were among the most frequently experienced sovereignty challenges—even ahead of cloud outages or cybersecurity incidents—although this figure was below the global average of 44%. This overarching AI category—which encompasses faulty AI outputs, model or provider failures, and general governance concerns—was cited more frequently by respondents than other events such as formal audits, data access issues, or government-imposed restrictions. As German industry increasingly adopts AI, companies that struggle to provide reliable evidence of control over their AI may find that this limits their operational flexibility at critical moments.

Continuous Testing as a Daily Discipline

Companies that treat demonstrating sovereignty not just as a crisis response but as a daily discipline have an advantage: According to the study, leading organizations test their ability to provide evidence more frequently as part of continuous processes or through regular governance measures. In addition, they are more than twice as successful at managing a sovereignty incident without significant business disruption.

Detlev Klage, Deputy Chairman of the Executive Board at Finanz Informatik (FI), adds: “We are convinced that AI will be indispensable for future resilience, but this requires more than just the implementation of individual use cases. A comprehensive strategy is needed that offers the flexibility to deploy the right models in a complex multi-tenant environment while ensuring the security, reliability, and quality that customers expect.” 

Research Methodology 

The IBM Digital Sovereignty Index was developed as part of a multi-stage research program that combined an analysis of 27 sources—including legislation, standards, governance frameworks, academic research, and industry thought leaders—was combined with qualitative interviews and an international quantitative survey.

As part of the quantitative study, 2,003 senior decision-makers at large enterprises in the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, Saudi Arabia, India, and Japan were surveyed (including 251 in Germany). The study also included 25 interviews with policymakers, regulatory authorities, public sector representatives, and policy experts, as well as the perspectives of 17 senior executives from the client side across five countries.

The index measures the extent to which an organization can demonstrate control across four pillars: AI, technology, operations, and data. Within these pillars, it assesses six dimensions of control: accountability, traceability, restriction, intervention, opt-out, and legitimacy.

To read “Proof, Not Promises: The Digital Sovereignty Index,” visit https://www.ibm.com/campaign/digital-sovereignty-index 

About IBM

IBM is a leading provider of global hybrid cloud and AI solutions, as well as consulting services. We help clients in more than 175 countries leverage insights from their data, optimize business processes, reduce costs, and gain a competitive edge. Thousands of governments and companies in critical infrastructure sectors such as financial services, telecommunications, and healthcare rely on IBM’s hybrid cloud platform and Red Hat OpenShift to drive their digital transformation quickly, efficiently, and securely. IBM’s groundbreaking innovations in AI, quantum computing, industry-specific cloud solutions, and consulting provide our clients with open and flexible options. All of this is built on the company’s longstanding commitment to trust, transparency, responsibility, inclusion, and service.

– – – – –

Related Links

👉 www.ibm.com   

Photo: IBM

Contact info

Silicon Saxony

Marketing, Kommunikation und Öffentlichkeitsarbeit

Manfred-von-Ardenne-Ring 20 F

Telefon: +49 351 8925 886

redaktion@silicon-saxony.de